Tobella Menu

Delivery Only Thur - Sat : 4pm - 10pm Made the New York Way. Delivered with Respect. At Tobella, we don’t do slices. We serve full 12-inch specialty pies, hand-stretched, stone-fired, and built with bold flavor and family tradition. Every pie is a made pie: crafted with care, layered with attitude, and sent hot to your doorstep like it just came from the back kitchen in Brooklyn. Our standard size is 12 inches, perfect for 1-2 people or 3 if you're feeling generous.

Signature Pies

The OG (Classic NY Cheese Pie)

New York-style pie layered with rich tomato sauce, whole milk mozzarella, and finished with a sprinkle of pecorino. Golden, foldable, and straight from the old ways. “No toppings. No talk. Just straight respect.” This is the pie your uncle grew up on, your cousin still orders, and the one the new guys better not mess up.

$17.99

Capo Bianca

A white pie made with creamy ricotta, fresh mozzarella, garlic confit, shredded pecorino, and an olive oil drizzle. No sauce — just flavor, layered like power.

$19.99

The Roni Doni

A NY-style pie stacked with crispy pepperoni cups, melted mozzarella, rich house red sauce, and a golden garlic-brushed crust. Finished with a pecorino rain and just enough oil to stain your knuckles.

$19.99

The Hitman

Vodka Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, Pecorino Romano, Basil. Silent but deadly. This pie comes dressed in creamy vodka sauce, loaded with melted mozzarella and a sharp Pecorino finish. No flash, no mess — just a clean job every time.

$19.99

Specialty Pies

La Famiglia Margherita

A 12-inch classic done the right way. Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and basil over a thin New York-style crust. Light, clean, and finished with a true taste of Italy.

$22.00